Hiring Strategy: Choosing an Assessment • Interview Scoring • Candidate Evaluation
If you have spent an afternoon trying to compare hiring assessment tools, you have probably noticed the problem. Most of them will not tell you what they cost.
We went through the public pages of six vendors in November 2026 and wrote down what each one says about itself. Three publish a price. Three ask you to book a call first. That difference matters more than most feature comparisons, because it tells you what kind of purchase you are making before you have spent an hour on a demo.
This is written for the person running a company of thirty or eighty people who needs to make a decision without a procurement process. We make one of these tools, and we have described ours the same way as the others, at the end, so you can judge it on the same terms.
First: these tools are not all doing the same job
The category name hides three fairly different things.
Skills and work-sample testing asks whether somebody can do the task. A typing test, a coding challenge, a job simulation. It answers a narrow question well.
Cognitive ability testing estimates how quickly somebody learns and solves unfamiliar problems. It has a long research record and it is also the part of assessment most likely to raise fairness questions, which is why the vendors who sell it talk a lot about validation and legal defensibility.
Behavioral or personality assessment describes how a person tends to work. How they communicate, what motivates them, how they respond to pressure. It does not measure capability, and a tool that implies otherwise is overselling what the research supports.
Several vendors do more than one. The useful question is which of the three you actually need, because buying all three when you needed one is the most common way this money gets wasted.
What they cost
Figures below are from each vendor’s own published pages, read on November 20, 2026. Where a vendor does not publish a price, we have said so rather than estimating.
| Tool | Published price | Can you start without talking to sales? |
|---|---|---|
| TestGorilla | Yes. Free tier, then from $215 a month billed annually | Yes |
| Talent Insights | Yes. Published annual rates starting at $1,500 | Yes |
| Predictive Index | Yes. From $10,000 a year, priced by headcount | PI says a trial can be enabled. Contact sales |
| Criteria | No. Three plans, priced on request | 14-day free trial, requested through a form |
| Wonderlic | No. Priced by package and employee count | No. Demo request only |
| Culture Index | No. No pricing page | No. Free diagnostic, followed by an advisor |
None of this makes the quote-only vendors worse. It does tell you something about how they expect to be bought, and if you are a forty-person company without a procurement function, that is worth knowing on day one rather than day twelve.
TestGorilla
TestGorilla is the skills-testing option here. It describes a library of more than 350 tests and leans on work samples, calling them “realistic job scenarios scored on real performance”. There are coding challenges, video questions and AI interviews alongside the tests.
It is also the most transparent vendor in this group on price. There is a genuinely free tier with ten credits a month, paid assessment plans from $215 a month billed annually, and separate per-seat pricing if you want its candidate sourcing. Core is described as “screening for smaller companies or limited hiring needs” and the higher tier as “for larger teams screening at scale”. You can sign up and try it without speaking to anybody.
If your question is whether a candidate can do the work, start here. The behavioral side exists, including a Big Five assessment, but skills are what the product is built around.
Predictive Index
PI is the best known name in behavioral assessment and has a long validation record behind it. The platform covers hiring, management and team design, built on a behavioral assessment and a cognitive assessment.
Their pricing page is unusually direct for this category: plans start at $10,000 a year, priced by your headcount, sold annually, with unlimited users and unlimited assessments included. Workshops, the PI Professional Certification and single sign-on are paid add-ons. Their FAQ says the product is “designed for companies with 50 to 500+ employees”.
That last line is the most useful sentence on their site. If you are above fifty people with somebody who owns hiring as part of their job, PI is a serious product and the price divides down sensibly. Below that, you are likely buying more platform than you will open. We wrote about this in more detail in what Predictive Index costs and who it fits.
Criteria
Criteria has the widest assessment range in this group. Cognitive aptitude, personality, emotional intelligence, risk and integrity, and practical skills, plus video interviewing with optional AI scoring. They are explicit about serving different sizes, with separate tracks for enterprise, mid-market and small business, which they define as fifty employees or fewer.
Pricing is not published. There are three plans, and the page asks you to request a quote “built around your headcount”. There is a fourteen-day free trial, though you request it through a form rather than starting it yourself. No certification is required, and the vendor says its customer success team helps you select assessments and interpret results.
Worth noting if AI governance matters to your industry: Criteria states it is certified to ISO 42001, the AI management standard, and says every score is “explainable and defensible”.
Wonderlic
Wonderlic has been doing this since 1937, which is longer than most of the category has existed. Wonderlic Select combines cognitive ability, personality and motivation into a single score, and the company leans on validation and legal defensibility in how it describes the product.
Product pricing is not published. The site says it depends on the package and your employee count, and the only route in is a demo request.
There is one thing here worth reading carefully, because the vendor says both halves of it. Their Select page states “No paid certifications are needed” and the homepage says there is “no lengthy training or certification required”. They also sell a two-day Foundations Certification workshop, and that is priced publicly: $2,500 for one attendee, $2,250 each for two to three, $2,000 each for four or more, and from $12,000 for teams of six or more. Both statements are true at once. The tool works without the workshop, and the workshop is a real product they sell. Just know which one you are being quoted.
Culture Index
Culture Index sells a behavioral survey that takes under eight minutes, wrapped in a set of tools for role benchmarking, structured interviewing and candidate tracking. One of those, their analytics product, the vendor describes on its own site as “currently in early development”, which is a more honest thing to publish than most roadmaps.
What distinguishes Culture Index is not the instrument. It is that an advisor comes with it. Their site says “Real advisors, not algorithms” and describes an Executive Advisor involved at every stage, including reviewing the data with your leadership team. The entry point is a free diagnostic, followed up by that advisor.
There is no published pricing and no self-serve path. If you want a person who knows the methodology sitting with your leadership team, that is the offer and it is a coherent one. If you wanted software, this is a consulting relationship with software attached, and the price will reflect that.
Talent Insights
Ours, described on the same terms as the rest.
A fifteen-minute assessment combines three established frameworks into one result: a 16-type personality model, DISC and the Holland Code. The report is written as guidance rather than as scores to interpret, which matters because the person reading it is usually the person running the interview. Around it sit the tools a manager opens during a hire. Writing or generating a job description, comparing candidates against it, building a structured interview guide with a scorecard, and setting a benchmark from the people already doing the job well.
Published pricing starts at $1,500 a year, on our pricing page. There is a free trial you can start yourself. We do not sell certification and do not require it.
We built this for companies where the person hiring is also the person who will manage the hire. If you have an HR function and a five-figure budget, the larger platforms in this list will give you more than we do.
Three questions that sort the field faster than a feature list
Which of the three questions are you actually asking? Can this person do the work, how fast do they learn, or how will they operate on my team. Most tools answer one well and the others adequately. Buying for all three usually means paying for two you will not use.
Who reads the output? If the answer is a trained person who then advises the manager, you are buying a methodology and a relationship as well as software, and you should price the whole thing. If the manager reads it directly, find out whether the report is written for them or for a specialist.
What happens in month four? Assessment tools get used hard during onboarding and then quietly stop. Ask what you would open it for when you are not hiring. A tool nobody has touched since March is the one that gets cancelled in December, and that is the real cost of buying more platform than you needed.
One caution about the category
Assessments describe differences in how people work. They do not rank people as better or worse, and no assessment in this list should be used on its own to screen somebody out. The evidence is strongest when a structured instrument is one input among several, which is why the tools that do the most for a small employer tend to be the ones that feed something, like a structured interview, rather than producing a verdict.
If you want somewhere to start that costs nothing, our piece on scoring structured interviews consistently covers the part most hiring processes get wrong, with or without an assessment attached.
Figures and quotations in this article come from each vendor’s public pages, read on November 20, 2026. Vendors change pricing and packaging, so check the current figures with the vendor before deciding anything.
Hire Better and
Manage Smarter
We combine 3 proven, established assessments into one, giving you the most comprehensive view of a person.
Are you seeking an assessment for personal use? Click Here